Can You Actually Make Money By Reviewing Music?

Enter Slicethepie, the online platform where you can earn money by reviewing music, fashion, commercials, and more. Is it a game-changer for side hustlers, or does the whole thing feel like a bad song stuck on repeat? Read on for the pros, cons, and whether Slicethepie is worth your time.

What Exactly is Slicethepie?

Slicethepie is an online crowd-sourcing platform where you, the reviewer, earn money by sharing your thoughts on various types of content. Whether it’s music, fashion, or ads, your feedback helps artists and brands improve their products. It’s kind of like giving a product a performance review, except you’re not getting a promotion for your stellar work.

A woman in cowboy boots sitting on the grass, playing the guitar.

How Does It Work?

  • Sign Up: Create a free account. No membership fee. That’s a win.
  • Review Content: Listen to a track, look at a fashion design, or watch an advertisement. Then, write a review based on your impressions. Quality counts here—trust me, your generic “cool” comments won’t make you rich.
  • Earn Money: Depending on the quality of your review, you’ll earn a small amount of cash per review. The more detailed and thoughtful your feedback, the more money you make.
  • Withdraw Earnings: Once you’ve hit a $10 minimum payout, you can withdraw your earnings via PayPal. 

How Much Can You Earn?

You’re not going to retire off Slicethepie. Or maybe even make enough money to withdrawal. But it can add up if you’re VERY patient (and persistent). Here’s a breakdown of how much you can expect to make per review:

  • Music Reviews: Apparently, you can earn anywhere between $0.02 to $0.20 per review. That’s right, you could spend a solid 3-5 minutes analysing a song’s hook, chorus, and overall vibe… and earn less than a dollar. But, the key to unlocking higher payouts? Detailed reviews. Forget your one-line “It’s good” comments—Slicethepie rewards depth!
  • Fashion & Other Products: For fashion and products, you’ll (apparently) earn between $0.10 to $0.50 per review. It sounds a bit better, but don’t expect to make it rain unless you’re reviewing hundreds of items each day. The more specific your review, the better the payout.
  • Minimum Withdrawal: You need at least $10 to cash out. This isn’t exactly an “easy-peasy” threshold, considering how long it might take you to rack up the money with those low payouts. Some users report that hitting the $10 mark could take weeks, especially if you’re casually reviewing one or two items a day. I think for me personally it would take more like months…

Real-World Example: The (Not-So-Lucrative) Reality of Reviewing Music

I listened to a song for around 3 minutes and 31 seconds, and then spent 3 minutes writing a review. What was the reward for my work? A whopping $0.03.

I looked up people’s tips online for earning more. The advice I was given was to be detailed, descriptive, and avoid sounding like a broken record. For instance, try describing the track’s structure, the melody, and the mood it creates. Talk about the vocals, the chorus, the instrumentation, and so on. Use fancy adjectives like “melancholic,” “soulful,” and “rhythmic.” The longer and more descriptive your review, the more likely you are to get paid higher. Apparently if you rush through a review with a lazy “meh, it’s fine” response, don’t expect to make it rain. Instead, you’ll be stuck in the “low-earnings limbo.”

I did a second review. $0.03 again for a similar amount of work reviewing a cheesy wedding song.

Then a third time… but this time I made it as long as I could possibly make it… $0.03.

If you’re looking for a way to kill time and earn a tiny bit of cash in the process, it can be mildly entertaining. Plus, it’s oddly satisfying to critique music or fashion items from the comfort of your couch or on the bus.

A man playing guitar on stage at a concert, immersed in his performance.

Pros and Cons of Slicethepie

Pros

  • Easy to Sign Up: No hidden fees or complicated sign-up processes. You’re in within minutes.
  • Flexible Work: You can work from anywhere, as long as you have an internet connection. This means no more pretending to be busy at work while you’re really in your pajamas on the couch.
  • Great for Music Lovers: If you’re into music and enjoy critiquing songs, this is an easy way to turn your passion into pennies (or dimes, if you’re lucky).
  • Variety of Content: You can review not just music but fashion, commercials, and other products. If you like variety, Slicethepie has you covered.

Cons

  • Low Pay: The pay per review is REALLY low. Even if you’re writing reviews for hours every day, you’re likely to make only pocket change.
  • Time-Consuming for Low Payout: To hit that $10 payout threshold, you’ll need to grind for weeks or months. It’s not exactly a “get rich quick” scheme.
  • Generic Reviews Won’t Cut It: If you want decent pay, you’ll need to put in the effort with detailed reviews. This can feel like an unpaid writing gig with a small reward at the end.
  • Very Slow Earning Potential: It can take quite a bit of time to accumulate enough for a withdrawal, especially if you’re not pumping out reviews like a machine.
A woman relaxing on a couch, wearing headphones and enjoying music.

Overall Score: 4.5/10

SliceThePie is an easy way to earn (very) small amounts of cash by reviewing music, fashion, and other products. While it requires no start-up costs and offers flexibility, the low income potential and time-consuming nature make it less attractive as a serious side hustle.

  • Start-Up Costs: 10/10 – Completely free to join. No upfront investment required.
  • Time Commitment: 3/10 – Requires a lot of time to make even a few dollars. The reviews must be detailed, and payments per review are low.
  • Income Potential: 2/10 – Payments range from a few cents to around 20 cents per review, depending on quality and rating. Making even $5 can take hours.
  • Fun Factor: 5/10 – If you enjoy music or reviewing products, it can be enjoyable at first. However, the novelty wears off due to the low pay.
  • Flexibility: 9/10 – You can work whenever you want with no strict schedule, making it flexible.

Final Thoughts:

SliceThePie can be fun for music lovers and those looking for a casual way to make a little extra cash. However, it’s not a reliable or efficient way to earn money. If you’re looking for an online side hustle with better income potential you should check out paid surveys.